Switch For UK Public Charge Point Regulation Compliance

Say goodbye to inflexible networks: The Switch App Store is here!

We believe sharing knowledge and helping others in the e-mobility industry to innovate is the way forward – for all of us. That’s why we created our Switch webinar series because by learning and working together, we’ll get there quicker.

‍

On Friday, 15 July 2022, we presented “Switch x Nuvve: V2G rollouts in local markets”, episode five of our popular webinar series.

This webinar is for you if:

you have ever wondered how to take your fleet into an electrified future
you manage a fleet or even drive a company vehicle
you have been curious about the switch to electric fleet vehicles.

We have partnered with the global cleantech leader Nuvve to improve interoperability among critical electrified transportation components: charging stations, EVs, and the grid.

Our webinar speakers were: Marc Mültin (Founder and CEO, Switch), Adam Chilab (Chief Product Officer, Switch), Hamza Lemsaddek (Director, Embedded Solutions, Nuvve Corp.) and Parth Gadhavi (Product Manager V2X, Nuvve Corp.).

In the live webinar, we discussed:

software is the new Infrastructure - how remote diagnostics and fleet management software combine to make EVs more realistic for your fleet
the differences between V2H (vehicle-to-home), V2B (vehicle-to-building/business), V2L (vehicle-to-load) and V2G (vehicle-to-grid)
the power of V2G - multiple use-cases and deployments.
‍

Here’s the recording of 'Switch x Nuvve: V2G rollouts in local markets' webinar.‍

We dedicated the last 15 minutes of the webinar to questions. Each question and answer is detailed below, so you can find all you need on V2G rollouts in local markets. Enjoy!

If there are any other specific questions you would like us to answer, shoot me an email at marc@switch-ev.com.

Want to see a demo of the Switch Platform? You can book a demo here today.

‍

Q. What do you think about the future of AC V2G?

‍Marc: Most car manufacturers are currently focusing on DC bi-directional charging. However, some car manufacturers are already experimenting with AC and doing AC V2G.

There’s a famous project in Utrecht, Germany, on V2G charging infrastructure and how it is helping Utrecht move towards being the first bi-directional city in the world. You can watch it via Robert Llewellyn’s Fully Charged Show here. It’s very interesting.

There is a bit of a split in the OEM and car manufacturing industries. Some favour more AC, some more DC and others are undecided. It's hard to say.

When you look at workplace and home charging, I think it depends on the use case, where AC chargers might still be cheaper than DC regarding bi-directional charging. I see more of a use case there. Whereas in fleet charging, especially when you have buses and heavy-duty vehicles with big batteries, DC V2G might be more of a sensible solution.

‍
‍Hamza: I think it's going to be a mix. There's a different use case for AC V2G. We are trying to overcome some regulatory barriers here - compliance grid codes, for example. The use cases of the fleets will drive it. There's definitely a place for AC V2G. Many OEMs are interested in it, especially in the light-duty segment.

‍

Q. Has ISO 15118 been reconciled with California’s Rule 21?

‍Marc: There is currently a discussion going on in California whereby this Rule 21 currently specifies an IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) standard called IEEE 2030.5. It’s formerly known as the smart energy profile 2.0, which is basically a protocol defined by the utility industry in North America.

Rule 21 defines that this standard (or protocol), or the capabilities provided by this standard, must be implemented into all inverters, including onboard charges in vehicles connected to the grid.

However, if you read Rule 21 carefully, it says that the capability doesn’t have to be provided by that specific protocol, and it doesn't exclude other protocols.

So in other words, the inverter must be certified to that IEEE standard, but you may use other communication protocols, such as ISO 15118 and OCPP. We do of course need OCPP to be compliant with the grid codes. The common smart inverter profile (CSIP) task force is working on it at the moment, and with the next version 2.1, we will have a version that is really critical-compliant.

Hamza: ISO 15118 covers the communication between the vehicle and the ABS. In the case of a DC charging station, though, it doesn’t really matter.

In the case of AC V2G, it becomes a little more complicated, especially in other fields. There is the task force working on UL 1741-SC.

UL 1741-SC has multiple system types, one of which requires IEEE 2030.5 communication between the EV and electric vehicle supply equipment (EVSE). What we are looking at now is expanded ISO 15118 to include some of those grid settings, especially for California.

Q. Which countries are ready to make money with grid services already (eg. frequency containment reserves) and which ones will follow next?

‍Parth: Let’s look at this based on the current market dynamics. We are running commercial fleets in the Nordics and Scandinavia, and they have been operational for a long time. That's why we know we can provide services such as frequency containment reserves (FCR).

There are also ancillary services in those regions and scope for flexibility services. We have some operations in Spain and Portugal where we are carrying out demand charge management, and these services provide flexibility to the grid.

In North America, we have programmes in California and the New England region. These programmes, such as Bring Your Own Device and Connected Solutions, mean we can enable scheduled discharges. The market is opening up and V2G has great potential.

‍

Hamza: Ancillary services exist everywhere. It's about market access from V2G and vehicles, and that's why our regulatory group is working on this to enable those V2G markets.

FCR exists all across Europe, and now in Spain and Portugal, although the market access there is not as easy as it is in France, for example in our dream joint venture is carrying out FCR in the USA.

We've been performing regulation D in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Maryland (PJM), as well as in California. We've had a couple of pilot projects providing regulation, but a lot of the services that we see in the USA are targeted at the distributor level. In the UK, they're more interested in local flexibility services, but the new markets exist. It's all about access. And the answer is that, today, we can access a lot of those markets.

‍

Q. What are the communications links Nuvve uses in its V2G pilots? How much does it cost per month and what percentage up time does it provide?

‍Hamza: Nuvve does pilots but we are also providing these services commercially. In terms of the communication we use with assets or infrastructure? We tend to push for a LAN connection, as we find it more reliable. However, we have fallbacks for Wi-Fi, for example the up time we’ve achieved varies by region. It's over 99% on average. And the cost also varies per region. We're looking at less than $10 per charger for long-term evolution (LTE)-enabled devices, because we're working on optimising the communication between the charger and the cloud.

‍

Q. Is ISO 15118-20 compatible or does it conflict with the development of J3072 and UL 1741-SC in California?

‍Hamza: So, UL 1741-SC does not specify ISO 15118 but we're looking at the extensions required for ISO 15118-20 to be in line with UL 1741-SC.

At the end of the day, it's about communicating the settings and information between the charger and the EV. I don't see many conflicts, but I do see some gaps in the industry that need to be filled. Of course, the task force for CSIP has not considered ISO 15118-20, but I'm sure in the next revisions, they will consider it, especially with the push in the USA for ISO 15118.
‍

Want to see a demo of the Switch Platform? You can book a demo here today.

‍

‍Abbreviations

CSIP = Common Smart Inverter Profile
EV = Electric Vehicle
EVSE = Electric Vehicle Supply Equipment
FCR = Frequency Containment Reserves
IEEE = Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers
LTE = Long-term Evolution
OCPP = Open Charge Point Protocol
OEM = Original Equipment Manufacturer
V2B = Vehicle-to-Building/ Business
V2G = Vehicle-to-Grid
V2H = Vehicle-to-Home
V2L = Vehicle-to-Load
V2X = Vehicle-to-Everything

Marc Mültin

Marc, the Founder and CEO of Switch, has over 13 years of experience in the e-mobility space and holds a PhD in Computer Science. He is the leading global expert and co-author of international EV communication standards (ISO 15118 & OCPP 2.0.1) that underpin the Switch platform.

— Connect with

Marc Mültin

Webinar series - Switch x Nuvve: V2G rollouts to local markets

We believe sharing knowledge and helping others in the e-mobility industry to innovate is the way forward – for all of us. That’s why we created our Switch webinar series because by learning and working together, we’ll get there quicker.

Here’s the recording of 'Switch x Nuvve: V2G rollouts in local markets' webinar.‍

We dedicated the last 15 minutes of the webinar to questions. Each question and answer is detailed below, so you can find all you need on V2G rollouts in local markets. Enjoy!

Q. What do you think about the future of AC V2G?

Q. Has ISO 15118 been reconciled with California’s Rule 21?

Q. Which countries are ready to make money with grid services already (eg. frequency containment reserves) and which ones will follow next?

Q. What are the communications links Nuvve uses in its V2G pilots? How much does it cost per month and what percentage up time does it provide?

Q. Is ISO 15118-20 compatible or does it conflict with the development of J3072 and UL 1741-SC in California?

Want to see a demo of the Switch Platform? You can book a demo here today.

‍

Related reads

The challenges of migrating EV charging networks

Plug & Charge vs. Autocharge

Switch For UK Public Charge Point Regulation Compliance

Latest News

How our client built their EV charging service using the Switch API

The challenges of migrating EV charging networks

Plug & Charge vs. Autocharge

Thoughts on reliability from ICNC 2024

Switch For UK Public Charge Point Regulation Compliance

Josev v1.0: A giant leap for EV charging

NEVI funding: What is it and what are its requirements?

Autocharge: What it is – and why it’s a bad idea

Say goodbye to inflexible networks: The Switch App Store is here!

EV roaming: Switch users can now benefit from Europe’s leading roaming hub

EV charging: Creating premium hardware that works every single time

Why are so many EV chargers broken - and how can we fix this?

What is OCPP 2.0.1 and why does it matter?

Switch achieves dual OCPP 2.0.1 certification for future-proof EV charging infrastructure

Next-generation EV charging management

A round up of 2022 and what’s to come

Webinar series - Make the Switch: the benefits of partnering with Switch

Switch’s Android for EV chargers: supercharge recurring revenue

Switch at ICNC 2022: Plug and Charge, now also for AC chargers

Webinar series - Switch x Nuvve: V2G rollouts to local markets

Webinar series - Switch Platform: where design meets tech

Charging Communication with ISO 15118 (July 2022)

Introducing Josev Community

Why we support Eden Reforestation Projects - and how you can, too

Webinar series - What’s new in ISO 15118-20?

Webinar series - The Case for OCPP 2.0.1

The four key ingredients for a thriving e-mobility ecosystem

Are your EV charging solutions interoperable – or are you out?

What is ISO 15118?

Investment in Switch tackles poor public charging experience

Panel discussion with ISO 15118 industry leaders

AMA - Ask Me Anything (11/21)

V2G Clarity is now Switch

Charging Communication with ISO 15118 | Advanced Training

Charging Communication with ISO 15118 | Basic Training

The basics of Plug & Charge

Webinar: meet ISO 15118 in the context of smart charging

A joint solution for ISO 15118 and OCPP 2.0.1 compliance tests

Crowdfunding an operating system for EV charging infrastructure

Why the application guide VDE-AR-E 2802-100-1 is vital in a Plug & Charge ecosystem

The new features and timeline for ISO 15118-20

How measurement and calibration law affects EV charging infrastructure

V2G Clarity takes action on climate change & you can too

Auto Motor Sport podcast about ISO 15118 (in German)

How KOSTAL uses RISE V2G to test ISO 15118 onboard charge controllers

A comparison of Autocharge and ISO 15118's Plug & Charge

What are vehicle-to-grid services?

How does ISO 15118 support vehicle-to-grid (V2G)?

Keynote talk on ISO 15118

Next generation ISO 15118 introduces wireless and bidirectional charging

EV charging communication events and trends in 2019

The road to IEC 63110 and how you can impact the international standard

The solution to seamless interoperability: the CharIN CCS Test System

Videos from 8th International CCS & ISO/IEC 15118 Testing Symposium

Save-the-date: April 19-20 marks 8th ISO 15118 Testing Symposium

The case for ISO 15118 and OCPP 2.0: preventative solutions to hacking charging infrastructure

The battle between ISO 15118 and DIN SPEC 70121

Project Ultra-E realises key public infrastructures are needed for Plug & Charge

Bulletproof ISO 15118 implementation - RISE V2G tested by Verisco test system

Is your ISO 15118 solution ready? RISE V2G 1.0 has finally arrived

6th International ISO 15118 Interoperability and Conformance Testing Symposium

IEC 63110 - standardising the management of EV (dis-)charging infrastructures

5th Internat. ISO/IEC 15118 Testing Symposium in South Korea | Work on Edition 2 in Rome

The charging stations' backend protocol OCPP will evolve - through Oasis and IEC